Today, we celebrate the Epiphany of the Lord. The Magi follow the star and offer their gifts of gold, frankincense, and myrrh to Mary, Joseph, and the newly born Jesus. But the story of the Magi does not end with their offerings. We learn that “having been warned in a dream not to return to Herod, they departed for their country by another way.”
Herod had instructed the Magi to return and report the location of the Messiah. Yet, the Magi chose to disobey this authority. I imagine they followed their hearts, values, faith, and convictions to disregard the directives of a ruler, challenging his legitimacy out of deep care and belief. Admittedly, this part of the story is one I have often overlooked. Obedience is a value in our society and our Church. Like many, I have disobeyed authority before—sometimes out of whimsy or anger. But the Magi’s actions reflect something deeper: an intentional act of disobedience and of actively choosing “another way” toward life and love.
As a member of the Church, I’ve also grappled with going “another way.” I’ve experienced, at the personal and collective level, instructions, words, or directives of Church leaders to be in conflict with my heart, values, faith, and convictions. These directives have included who can be what kind of leader in our church, as well as who is truly welcome and fully embraced.
Herod’s intentions were clear: violent and self-serving. The intentions of today’s Church leaders may be less so. Yet, as I often remind my students, intent does not justify impact. The exclusion and marginalization caused by some words and teachings are evident. The impact is a community where not everyone is welcome. This is not the Church I was raised to believe in. And so, I practice a faithful, discerning disobedience. Like the Magi, I choose another path—walking with others committed to life, dignity, and the principles of Catholic Social Teaching.
The Magi also serve as a compass for how I approach the broader social and political challenges we are facing at this time. The incoming presidential administration has stated policy objectives that put many people at risk, especially Black, Indigenous, and People of Color; queer and trans folks; immigrants; disabled individuals; and those who are poor or working-class. We are called to discern when and how to disobey authority to protect our siblings. In what ways, big and small, may we be able to refuse to comply with a system that undermines the humanity and safety of our community members? Of course, disobedience carries potential risks: to our jobs, reputations, and stability. But the Magi remind us that we do not walk alone. Their community of three inspires me to lean into the collective strength of others who are committed to justice and dignity.
Today, as we celebrate Jesus being made known to the world, may we reflect on when we are called to choose “another way.” Let us do so with courage, love, and faith, facing risks and uncertainties together.
Comments